Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Google Maps VS Bing Maps (for India)

With the world turning to Google for all it's answers, it's simply so convenient to just use Google for everything. Majority of us use gmail and gtalk, but other than this, Google basically offers it's users EVERYTHING under one roof.

One of the most used services in almost all countries is Google Maps. It was the simple, convenient and gave the user a free and easy way to get directions and simply print them out. Nowadays, it even gives directions using public transport (in most major countries where the public transport is very well organized=> not in India for sure).
Now, just last year Bing was launched by Microsoft. I never thought it would be able to beat Google, but, at least with respect to Maps in India, it has come close.
Google Maps in India aren't very accurate or correct for that matter. I recently found myself at some government run school ( Lokhmanya Tilak High School) instead of the private school - Bombay Scottish School(acc to google & acc to Bing, bing is correct) because it seems who ever made the map, clearly was wrong. Bing Maps however, was very accurate with every building I've checked.
Other than this, Google Maps in Mumbai at least, seem to be showing results, but the balloons of those results are far away from the actual place on the maps. I'm not saying Bing Maps is more accurate, it's also horribly off the actual mark (worse than google maps) in India and Bing Maps takes waaayyy more time to load as compared to Google Maps.
There is only one other plus point I've found of Bing Maps compared to Google Maps, it has many paths which google maps have ignored, specifically, paths which are only meant for walking (which we usually call short cuts where it's impossible for a car to go).

I have used Google Maps for other (so called) 1st world countries like USA and in Europe, they are really accurate there. And with Street View in Google Maps, its absolutely brilliant since you can even see the place where you're heading to. This feature is missing in Bing, but then, in India, it's missing in both. So no one wins points for this in the Indian Version.

I find these free maps very useful for finding my way in other countries, but I guess when at home, I'll go what all Indian's do, use our even simpler method of finding places and directions: just ask someone on the way. Since our population is so large, odds are if you ask 2-5 people you'll get the route figured out. This works for all directions, by car, bus or train.

In the end, I guess I would say Bing Maps is a better option for finding places in India and otherwise, there is no competition for Google Maps.